Pendant Light Poll - Yay or Nay?

Yay or nay?

{Skip right to the end of this post to answer the poll if you don't feel like reading my nattering or scrolling through a thousand pictures.}

I've got a light fixture dilemma. You're smart. Maybe you can help!

As you probably already know I've been looking and looking for a light fixture for our breakfast room. I kept imagining an old-fashioned pendant light kind of like this (but the 10" one not the 8" one that's pictured):

I looked at a few small, dainty lights like these:

I looked at some drum shades like this:

And this:

I looked at some funky lights like this:

And this:

But they are all just sooooo much money ( + shipping, handling, and duties). So far I've held off on purchasing one. 

Until a few days ago. When I wandered into the lighting aisle at Home Depot and saw a cute, white, drum shade pendant light that was only.......

$39.99

What?!? Most of the lights I was looking at online were $139.99 or more.

Pros: Cute, white, & cheap.

Cons: Chrome finish, it's not really old-fashioned looking like I was picturing.

Oh, did you want to see it in the room? Okay. Alex installed it just to see if we like it and want to keep it.

{Please remember that the room is still in progress. That creamy table will be getting a fresh coat of white very soon. Those chairs will also be recovered once I find the perfect fabric.}

Well?

View from the kitchen.

Close-up of pattern.

With the light on.

Close-up with light on.

Chrome.

So, I need to decide if I should keep the light as is, spraypaint the chrome hardware, or return it and keep searching for a different fixture altogether. What do you think?

Drum Shade Pendant - Should I...